Bubbles,
You are not wrong to want borders. Or order. Or laws that mean something. I would never suggest we throw open the gates and pretend it’s all fine when it’s not. There are real flesh-and-blood challenges walking across that southern border—some broken, some dangerous, all made in the image of God. That matters.
But here’s where I believe we part ways: you see this as solely a legal matter, while Scripture calls us to view it as a spiritual one first.
Yes, we have immigration laws. And yes, violating them has consequences. But as believers, we’re not just lawkeepers—we’re peacemakers, image-bearers, ministers of reconciliation (2 Corinthians 5:18). Our lens must always be wider than the Constitution—it must be eternal.
As for international law, I’ll simply say this: the U.S. is not bound by the UN’s definition of a refugee in determining its own moral response. Scripture doesn’t command us to enforce proximity clauses. It tells us to “love the sojourner, for you were sojourners in the land of Egypt” (Deut. 10:19). That’s not policy—it’s posture.
Now, your comment about Heaven having a gate and a vetting process? It made me smile. You’re right—Heaven is not open borders. But here’s the twist: none of us get in on merit. The gate is Christ. The password is grace. And the scandal of the gospel is that it throws open the gate to every unworthy sinner—Jew, Gentile, legal, illegal, tax collector, Samaritan, thief on a cross. If Heaven were run on the kind of moral immigration policy we sometimes demand on Earth, not one of us would make it through.
You say Jesus was not a refugee, and you’re free to hold that view. But He was hunted by a king, carried away to a foreign land under threat of death, and returned only after the tyrant died (Matthew 2:13–15). You can call that a family vacation if you want—but the Bible calls it deliverance.
I agree with you on one final point though, wholeheartedly: We need to be careful. But not just careful about borders. Careful that we don’t let fear take the pen and rewrite the gospel into something that guards gates more tightly than it opens arms.
Let’s be stalwart, yes. But also soft-hearted. Law and love aren’t enemies. In Christ, they’re married.