Does Struggling with Mental Health Mean You Lack Faith?

Does Struggling with Mental Health Mean You Lack Faith?

As more believers open up about emotional health, we have the opportunity to show that the Church is a place for healing—not shame.

#FaithAndMentalHealth #GraceInStruggle #ChurchSupport #christianforums #crosswalkforums #forums #crosswalk #faithcommunity #faithforums

Many believers silently wrestle with anxiety, depression, or other mental health challenges, wondering if these struggles reflect a weak or wavering faith. In some church circles, there’s still a quiet stigma—that if we really trusted God, we’d never feel overwhelmed, anxious, or broken. But is that true?

The Bible is full of godly men and women who faced deep emotional turmoil—Elijah asked God to take his life, David wept and poured out his soul in the Psalms, and even Jesus sweat drops of blood in anguish. Faith doesn’t always mean peace without struggle. Sometimes it means holding onto hope even when peace feels far away.

Does having a mental health battle mean your faith is lacking?

Here’s more on this topic:

5 Likes

Only if being overweight or having heart disease, diabetes or a broken leg.

a mental illness is just that an illness, an unseen illness that is very very common. but unfortunately not understood by ordinary people.

Talk to the mothers in your church and ask about post natal depression. something that is common and ask how did the church support them?

2 Likes

Mental heath isn’t what most people think in it is. Look at popular and child psychology coming out of Christian “independent ministries”. The new charter school/school choice voucher schools separatist & sectarian groups advocate “making the core knowledge in the Bible the basis of the psyche”.

What you have to do is pick up the Bible and make sure you know the Bible passages yourself. This isn’t knowledge in the sense of a formula someone else distilled from their thesis paper, make sure you memorize the core text (there’s a basic 66 Book “Bible”). Psychology ranges from casual support conversation strong the office water cooler to really freaky Charles Manson control weirdoness.

As far as God and mental health, I’d just push ignore and swipe to the left, if at all possible. Let me put it to you this way, ever read Sigmond Freud’s book “Dream Psychology”? Ok, what happened when Nebuchadnezzar got all cozy with Daniel and told his dream, looking for the interpretation? He was deposed. It’s in chapter four of Daniel. And what happened in dream psychology when Joseph talked about his dream in Genesis? Sold into Egyptian slavery! Modern example: Martin Luther King marched on Washington and deliver the @I had a dream speech. What became of him? Electric chair for incitement to riot and disorderly conduct - disturbing the peace.

Just a warning, for your own good: stay away from psychs.

1 Like

I had no idea MLK got the electric chair. I thought he was assassinated. Not sure what his speech has to do with mental health, however, I trust in mental health professionals.

1 Like

Executed by order of the United States Attorney General. It’s debated though, Black Lives Matter includes a few more people like the Irish members of U2, who made your claim in their song Pride in the Name of Love.

1 Like

Wait, was he assassinated by the US Attorney General or given the electric chair? I do not recall making a claim or how any of this relates to black lives matter and a 1984 song by U2. The song mentioned MLKs assassination.

That’s their opinion. The band thought his execution was illegal.

Have you ever met U2? Just wondering I once met them in London at Wimbly Arena.

Absolutely not. C.S. Lewis wasn’t officially diagnosed with clinical depression, he experienced profound periods of sadness, despair, and spiritual darkness, particularly after World War I trauma (PTSD) and the death of his wife, Joy Davidman, leading to symptoms described as depression, though he framed them as deep grief, spiritual struggle, and existential pain, coping through writing like “A Grief Observed.”

Many well-known Christians, including biblical figures and historical or modern leaders, struggled with depression. This list features King David, Elijah, Martin Luther, Charles Spurgeon, Mother Teresa, and Martin Luther King Jr., showing that faith doesn’t prevent mental health struggles but provides resources to help endure them, as reflected in their writings and lives.

As

That is actually me that who-me described. Also, early COPD from 35 years of smoking. The broken leg came from a head-on car crash. Do I suffer from depression? Yes. Do I have issues with the other issues? Yes. Does that stop me from following Jesus and sharing His Word? Absolutely not.

In the long run, this broken-down shell will return to dust. I will be free with the Lord. All the praise and Glory be to God.
Peter

4 Likes

Fritz asks (rhetorically),

@Fritz_Admin et.al.
Both “faith” and “mind” are gifts; they are characteristics we may possess but did not earn, magnificent gifts of grace we received by executive fiat. Both are “wonderful” and both are “incomplete”; that is both are currently experiencing the miracle of growth. I am unsure how the idea came about that the reason our bodies suffer some malady is because we have failed to appropriate a sufficient quantity of faith;

This probably derives from a poor understanding of scripture, an erroneously appropriated understanding that tickles our ears and suits our desires. We are told that we failed to arrogate enough of God’s gift of Faith to overcome some malady or deficiency we see in ourselves; we didn’t grab enought of the gift that we didn’t ask for, one that we surely don’t deserve, and yet upon which the wonder and magnificence of our relationship with the omnipotent loving Father of all living resides. This idea I find to be illogical and contra-biblical. Surely, we are His workmanship, bumps, scratches, dents, and all.

The testimony of the grace of God is not that he called the well-deserving into the marriage banquet, but that He scoured the hedges and fence-rows for the infirmed, (Matt. 22:8-10), the weak, the needy, the sufferers of this world, and transformed them into nobility, kings and priests of the realm.

1 Corinthians 1:26-31

For you see your calling, brethren, that not many wise according to the flesh, not many mighty, not many noble, are called. But God has chosen the foolish things of the world to put to shame the wise, and God has chosen the weak things of the world to put to shame the things which are mighty; and the base things of the world and the things which are despised God has chosen, and the things which are not, to bring to nothing the things that are, that no flesh should glory in His presence. But of Him you are in Christ Jesus, who became for us wisdom from God–and righteousness and sanctification and redemption-- that, as it is written, “He who glories, let him glory in the LORD.” (1 Corinthians 1:26-31)

God did not look for perfectly whole people with whom He could fellowship. God chose broken people to make whole in eternity as an expression of His grace, for His glory alone. For that revealing, we eagerly wait.

While there are many in this world that possess no faith, I sincerely doubt there is a mortal mind on earth which does not carry some mental deficiency, some weakness in thought-processes that contrasts against their observable strengths. Even some who have the most profound deficiencies also have profound strengths. From all unbiased observances there seems to be no correlation between mental health and faith, or godliness. All believers have their share of each.

The apparent disconnect is that too many well-meaning charlatans, like Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar are propagating the error that any malady is the result of too much sin or too little faith. It simply is not the case. Likewise, too few saints are reminding their suffering brothers and sisters to give thanks in all things, especially in your suffering, for this is the will of God for you. Truth-bearing saints are reluctant to quietly suggest “Thanksgiving” as a response to suffering because the loud alternative suggestion of potential healing is so much more desirable to the flesh. Nevertheless, the biblical instruction to suffering is, and always has been, thanksgiving. You can hardly flip open a New Testament page without finding the admonition to thank God somewhere under your finger.

It seems too easy to quickly decontextualize the passage in the book of James that seems to promise healing through the performance of ritualistic observances, but the suggestion that the Elders pray in faith means that they pray in agreement with what God is doing, not demanding He do their will. The context of the entire letter (which begins by admonishing believers to count various trials as joy) is endurance through suffering, not promised relief from it. When we read the entire letter, the verses in 5:15 make much more sense.

James 5:13-16

Is anyone among you suffering? Let him pray. Is anyone cheerful? Let him sing psalms. Is anyone among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord. And the prayer of faith will save the sick, and the Lord will raise him up. And if he has committed sins, he will be forgiven. Confess your trespasses to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The effective, fervent prayer of a righteous man avails much. (James 5:13-16)

The fact that Fritz asked the question “Does Struggling with Mental Health Mean You Lack Faith?” means this philosophy is being promoted in Christian circles as we speak. It is patently untrue. It is incumbent on saints like us, to set straight the true teachings of Jesus, and to encourage one another to contentment, thanksgiving, and joy in The Lord in all circumstances, all the more as we see the day approaching.

Give thanks in all things
KP

2 Likes

OptionalAlgebra,

First you claim it was an electric chair, now it has something to do with U2… .

While your post is an important reminder of the importance of seeking mental health, I will disengage from further whatever that was.

Absolutely not ! You just need to give your mental to God

Who’s CS Lewis, I’ve never heard of him. Is he like Robert Clive, I think that’s been put by me before as a candidate for what the C. stands for. Well, Clive of India was um, a contemporary of Richard Kipling.

The only major or meaningful depression I know of that exists in the United States is one in Nevada near Reno, along a highway on your way to Arizona. Highway 40. It was caused by the Challenger in 1986. Oh wait. Salton Sea in Southern California has been there since before the battle of San Jacinto or thereabouts.

I’m sure you could do the research yourself, but here ya go.

“Clive Staples Lewis (1898–1963) was one of the intellectual giants of the twentieth century and arguably one of the most influential writers of his day. He was a Fellow and Tutor in English Literature at Oxford University until 1954, when he was unanimously elected to the Chair of Medieval and Renaissance Literature at Cambridge University, a position he held until his retirement.

Lewis wrote more than thirty books, allowing him to reach a vast audience, and his works continue to attract thousands of new readers every year. C. S. Lewis’s most distinguished and popular accomplishments include Mere Christianity, Out of the Silent Planet, The Great Divorce, The Screwtape Letters, and the universally acknowledged classics in The Chronicles of Narnia. To date, the Narnia books have sold over 100 million copies and been transformed into three major motion pictures.C. S. Lewis | The Official Website for C. S. Lewis and His Works

1 Like

Oh the anti intellectualism of American Christians.

Do you know your Christian heros, David Brainard, John Elliot, not forgetting Jim Elliot, or Johnathan Edwards.

As important as reading your bible is reading about the lives of faithful men like theses and of so many more.

1 Like