Is being “slain in the Spirit” biblical—or something else entirely?*

General Faith
107

The Holy Spirit would never work in a way that goes outside of God’s Word. Jesus said that His Word is truth (John 17:17). Paul says that we must not go beyond what is written (1 Corinthians 4:6). The fruit of the Spirit is what is found in Galatians 5:22–23. At no time is it listed as falling over in a “slaying in the Spirit” ritual. Every time a person in Scripture falls**, they are falling in fear and worship before the glory of God** (Ezekiel 1:28; Revelation 1:17). It is not something we do over and over in the church. The test is not feelings; the test is whether it is in line with Scripture. If it is not found in God’s Word, it is not of God.

It is never good to decide on your own what is right or wrong apart from God’s Word. The Bible is very clear that “The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it?” (Jeremiah 17:9). If you are going to lean on your own understanding, you are already in danger. Proverbs 3: 5–6 is a command to “Trust in the Lord with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding. In all thy ways acknowledge him, and he shall direct thy paths.”

God has already provided us with His truth in Scripture. Jesus said plainly, “Thy word is truth” (John 17:17). To set aside that truth and follow our own human reasoning is to set up man’s wisdom above God’s authority. Paul tells us that even if an angel from heaven preached a different gospel, we are not to receive it (Galatians 1:8). That is because the standard never changes. God’s Word is final.

The only safe way to test what is “OK” or “not OK” is to measure it against Scripture. Anything less opens the door to deception. Isaiah 8: 20 puts it very well: “To the law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.”

1 Like
108

“What are they testifying to?”, and ”clear in their worship” People who have been “slain in the Spirit” often tell of some vision they had with God or some word they got from God or some comfort that they got which had not come to them before. Things of God are not always clear, such as the translation of someone’s tongues prayer. That is way if it is in the congregation we would need interpretation of tongues. If God thinks you need to know what is happening in another Christian, then perhaps you can pray to God to tell you what it is. No, the worship of Christians is not always clear to others, but it is not we who need to be in control. We trust God to keep things decent and orderly but also in His control, not ours.

109

Again, falling in the Spirit is not a ritual. It is usually not something planned. God just makes it happen to minister to those who can be ministered to better this way than some other way. It is not similar to the sin of Nadab and Abihu or the making and worship of the golden calf. Those events took the hearts of men away from God almighty, but being slain or falling under the Spirit causes concentration to be on the Lord. The biblical and non-biblical experiences that are not pointed toward God or giving glory to Him are totally in another category than experiences and practices that do. Pentecostals accept the latter, but not the former. I think we leaders of believers need to consciously give the right of way to the Holy Spirit in our services, since it has become ordinary to rule out demonstrations of God’s power that we do not understand, and that is because we fear losing control of the services that are really the responsibility of Christ in His Church.

Which is real, what is visible or what is not?
110

Have you never been in a service that was decent and orderly but at the same time ruled not by the minister but by the Holy Spirit?. There is space given for some manifestation of Him or Hid power, but at the same time space for vernacular prayer, testimony, teaching or preaching. I do not enjoy services where everything is planned ahead of time and there is nothing ethereal or surprising in the service. Those services seem dead to me. I sometimes feel something is missing when everything is planned and in logical order. That would more probably be found during teaching times that are less formal. In worship services I look for the numinous in addition to what man can put together on his own. It is in those meetings that it is normal to be visited by God with Holy Spirit manifestations that are beyond natural ingenuity. In teaching we use the mind more, but in worship, we need to be more open to things beyond our reason. That is where I’ve experienced more, convictions and movements in my heart to love God more and to commit myself more or in some different way to Him. Inner mental conclusions about the sermon are not the only spirit movement in Christian services. Sometimes such inner experiences are expressed outwardly, but often held back due to embarrassment in some churches, where external expression is frowned upon. When we truly give the right of way to the Spirit, those personal encounters with God are

Which is real, what is visible or what is not?
111

@Peaceful23, I see your desire for something beyond the cold, clinical routine that can settle into church services. That hunger for the presence of God is right. But that’s exactly why discernment matters more, not less. A desire for the “numinous” without biblical boundaries leads to spiritual fog where anything that feels supernatural gets labeled “Holy Spirit” without testing the source.

Let’s start here. You say people testify of visions, words, comfort, even guidance during these “slain” moments. That may be their experience, but experience is not self-validating. The Bible gives us strict parameters for evaluating every spiritual manifestation. Paul didn’t tell the Corinthians to let it flow. He rebuked them for letting emotion and chaos eclipse truth and order. And that was a church full of tongues, prophecy, and gifts. The solution wasn’t more freedom. It was more order according to the Word.

You mention tongues needing interpretation, exactly. Why? Because God is not a God of confusion. If something is happening in a service and no one can say clearly what it is, it might feel spiritual, but that doesn’t mean it’s biblical. Paul told the Corinthians to speak with clarity so that the uninformed and unbelievers would fall down and say, “God is really among you.” That is not just spiritual. That’s convicting, coherent, and Christ-exalting.

Yes, the Holy Spirit should lead worship, but the real Spirit of God never contradicts the Word He wrote. He doesn’t manifest Himself in ways that disconnect from truth. He doesn’t promote spectacle. He convicts, transforms, speaks through the Word, and produces fruit. Not just goosebumps, but godliness.

The longing for mystery must never override the call to test the spirits. Because not every spirit that feels powerful is holy. And not every experience that feels divine is from God. The devil would love nothing more than to keep people chasing feelings while quietly drifting from truth.

I’m not against passion. I’m not against spiritual experience. But if we call something a move of the Holy Spirit, it better hold up to the Book the Holy Spirit inspired.

Sincere Seeker. Scripturally savage. Here for the Truth.

112

“The Church was never called to be emotionally driven. It was called to be Spirit-led, which means Word-shaped, truth-anchored, Christ exalting.” I generally agree, but I also know times when my mind is not the first thing satisfied in church. Sometimes I sense something from God that I cannot immediately understand or explain. Only with meditation and prayer and feeling from the Holy Spirit can I fully appreciate what God has been saying to my spirit. Meditation is not always longitudinal. It includes waiting without words and maybe apprehending something musically or poetically before catching on to a thought rationally. People who are incapable of this kind of meditation find it hard to value it in other people. The Spirit of God gives the Truths he wants us to have in every way that is necessary for all sorts of people. Yes, of course the written Word is what we use to measure whether these truths are correct and worthy of our faith. But while people are in the process are defining what they believe and stand for, we need to recognize those processes they go through.

113

Where in Scripture do you find believers being told to expect or seek these kinds of manifestations? The Spirit always works in line with the Word of God, not outside of it (John 16:13–14). If you can’t show it from the Bible, then it isn’t from the Holy Spirit.

114

@Peaceful23, I appreciate that you’re recognizing both the rational and the reflective, the mind and the mystery. That’s wise. God did make us whole people, and He can certainly speak through more than just academic study. He can stir the heart through music, awaken awe through beauty, and convict through silence. No argument there.

But here’s the line we can’t blur. The Spirit does not bypass truth just to give someone a feeling. He may stir the heart before the head fully catches up, but He never works in contradiction to the Word or in ways that leave it behind.

Yes, not every moment of revelation comes fully formed in logic. That’s why we test, reflect, meditate, and pray. But the moment we start defending experiences that cannot be defined or examined by the Word… especially ones that lead to questionable manifestations… we drift from discernment and slide into spiritual subjectivism.

You say we need to recognize the processes people go through. Absolutely. But we also need to call people out of the fog and into the light. God is not cryptic with His truth. The Spirit does not play hide and seek with doctrine. He reveals Christ clearly, glorifies Him openly, and works in ways that ultimately lead to obedience and clarity, not emotional ambiguity.

So yes, let’s be patient with people who are still figuring things out. But let’s also be bold in pointing them to the standard that never changes… the Word rightly handled, the truth clearly spoken, and the Spirit unmistakably known not by feeling alone, but by fruit.

Sincere Seeker. Scripturally savage. Here for the Truth.

115

I absolutely agree in every way with what you have said here.

116

1Cor. 14:26 is an example of a New Testament worship service. I have been in such services and felt it Spirit-led and exciting that God was there and actively leading us to Him through present-day manifestations of His Spirit, not just through preplanned scripts.

117

Of course we see evidence of the Holy Spirit’s control in whether a meeting is biblical and whether it is decent and orderly, whether it magnifies the Lord Jesus, whether it proclaims Him as Lord, whether it starts with acknowledging that God’s Son has come in the flesh, etc. Nothing in a manifestation, if it is from the Holy Spirit, will ever contradict the Bible, although it may help us understand or receive something better than we did before.

118

good morning god is good

1 Like
119

All the time.
And all the time, God is good.

And a Good day to you, Sir

120

You said, “Scripture never tells us to fall to demonstrate surrender”. I want to ask you what you would do in the home of one who is grieving, and they suddenly start letting tears fall. Would you tell that person that the Bible never tells us to cry to demonstrate our loss?

121

Apples vs Oranges. The physiological onset of tears of grieving does not logically relate to the phenomenon that is called “Slain in the spirit”.

122

1 Corinthians 14:26 is not a prescription for how services should be conducted today. It is part of Paul’s correction of disorder already happening in Corinth. The chapter makes clear that chaos was present, not something to be pursued, because “God is not the author of confusion, but of peace” ~1 Corinthians 14:33.

Paul lists what was occurring, psalms, teachings, tongues, revelations, interpretations, and then immediately places a governing rule over all of it: “Let all things be done unto edifying” ~1 Corinthians 14:26. He then restricts speaking, limits participation, requires interpretation, and commands silence where order or understanding is lost ~1 Corinthians 14:27–32, 40.

The point of the passage is not spontaneous manifestation, but restraint. Paul is not encouraging believers to seek experiences. He is shutting them down where they undermine understanding. Scripture consistently places the Spirit’s work in line with intelligible truth and instruction, not unregulated expression ~John 16:13–14; ~Romans 10:17.

123

When a congregation is small and intimate such worship services as this are biblical. I have been to such meetings where I saw and heard what I have to say were manifestations that the Spirit of Jesus was there. The meetings were decent and orderly. The leadership just had to trust the Spirit to keep order and allow all the people to be used in the gifts that God gave them, no matter whether those gifts were right-brain or left-brained. Everyone was valued, not just the rational and articular. It was exciting to see such fresh expressions of God’s truths and to see His theme running through the entire service overall. It was not just the leadership who ran the service, but the Lord. It humbled me and my faith grew as God’s word was our focus.

124

You said that such ways of worship as 1Cor.14:26 should not be pursued in modern churches, because Paul was just trying to regulate the Corinthian church, because they were in error. I find that such a pursuit as this would we healthy for any church that is small and intimate, and it is possible when the Holy Spirit is allowed right-of-way. Why should we fear letting all control go to the Spirit? Do we doubt that He can manage His people?

125

@Peaceful23

Your resolute defense of this practice, ironically called “slain in the Spirit” is commendable, and I sure admire how you have not backed down from your solid conviction these past eight months (this thread originating on May Day of this year). Still, your stalwart defense is always based in personal experience, emotional confirmations, and traditional teaching. All of these have their part in the Christian life, and none are to be discounted wholesale. I doubt none of the “evidences” you have explained to us, and I do not doubt your reliance on them. But experience, emotion, and tradition all must find their footing in the Holy Word of God, and this is where your argument fails to provide any connection. Not only is there no Biblical precedent for this practice, there is no ancillary Biblical encouragement for it. In fact, the practice itself contradicts much of what The Word of God teaches us about the influence and activity of The Holy Spirit of God, the one whom Jesus said would be our silent advocate, our perfect teacher, and our indwelling seal against ultimate destruction.

That said, I sure do appreciate the heart with which you approach the regular gathering of believers:

And:

Amen to that. Your awesome understanding of the need for yielding and sincerity in the gathering, and your expectation that God will lead His own worship are refreshing and admirable. I too long to experience a gathering of believers that is, as you suggest, intimate, yielded, and expectant of the indwelling Holy Spirit of God to move hearts and minds into worship in Spirit and Truth, “… for the Father is seeking such to worship Him. (John 4:23) Most naysayers who would criticize the kind of gathering that you describe are perfectly comfortable in a gathering that follows an annual liturgical script, or is little more than a preformatted performance of well-meaning actors, and well-paid professionals complete with loud pounding music and bright stage lighting. Sometimes it seems similar to the injustice of a black-suited Wall Street embezzler criticizing a rag-wearing shop-lifter for stealing.

We have all grown-up in our particular traditions, and we all weigh the “unknown” against what we have come to believe is “normal”. I have met very few who still seek the depth of sincerity and The Truth of corporate worship that would put their “normal” to shame. Jesus said The Father is seeking worshipers who worship in Spirit and in Truth, but there seems to be too few worshipers who are seeking The Father in the same way. I sense that you are, and I want to say so.

I still cannot see anything but an ironic display in the acting out of death (being slain) supposedly caused by the giver of life (Holy Spirit). I have personally never been moved to “collapse in ecstasy”, and I still find no Biblical support for the practice. I still do not accept describing worship as mere men “allowing the Holy Spirt His right-of-way”. We allow The Holy Spirit nothing. He “allows” us, but we never “allow” or control Him in any way. We are simply not that powerful. But, that aside, I do see your heart to listen to that still small voice that resides within, to yield, and to obey God in worship. Men look on the outward appearance of others and criticize, God looks on the heart and is pleased with the voice of His own Holy Spirit praising Him through the quickened souls of His beloved ecclesia.

Thanks for your gentle words and kind heart throughout this long discussion.

Love in Jesus
Merry God Incarnate Day
KP

126

To allow the Holy Spirit His freedom to lead any way that He wants is the very opposite of controlling Him, but your phraseology makes it as if they are the same and something Christians should not do. In 1Cor. 14:26 this is just a description of a first century church service, nothing bad or good about it. I find it an ideal and do want to see more services like it, you seem to not approve of it and prefer traditional services dominated perhaps by the preacher doing all the work. I find that service unhelpful to many people who cannot follow the logic and reason of the preacher’s points. Every person needs to be allowed to have some way of participating in the service and 1Cor. 14:26 is one way to assure this.