Is the 'Digital Church' Here to Stay—or Hurting Real Discipleship?
As Christians reflect on the future of community and spiritual growth, we invite your voice in Crosswalk Forums.
#DigitalChurch #RealDiscipleship #christianforums #crosswalkforums #forums #crosswalk #faithcommunity #faithforums
When churches were forced online during the pandemic, many called it a temporary shift. But years later, some congregations have embraced a fully digital model—offering livestreams, Zoom Bible studies, even virtual baptisms. Others see it as a compromise that can’t replace the accountability, presence, and personal connection of in-person fellowship.
Can church exist without physical gathering? Are screens simply a new medium for the same Gospel—or a substitute for real-life relationships and spiritual depth?
The early church broke bread together. Laid hands on the sick. Was sent out face-to-face. But in a global, tech-savvy culture, does insisting on a physical presence miss the opportunity to reach people where they are?
- Can true discipleship happen entirely online?
- What might we lose—or gain—if digital church becomes the new normal?
- Where do you draw the line between convenience and commitment in your faith community?
“Online connection is real—but is it enough?”
Read more here:
1 Like
This is such a great topic with so many rabbit holes. With the trend of mobile devices being the preferred vehicle for online surfing, on the surface it would seem that being able to pull in from the masses online and spread God’s word, this is ideal for our mandate. I would hope that in trying to lead, by living as Christians & through our online discussions (forum included), we are gaining converts to join our fellowship rather than making the thirsty lose interest.
In the article cited there was a line that stuck out to me;
There are staff and pastors ready to meet you and engage with you.
I have noticed some of my excellent fellows in this forum are seminary students, elders and former pastors (maybe current). Being an “older” novice to authentic bible study, it is intriguing to read the past and ongoing discussions.
Since I prefer in-person services and volunteer to help individuals with substance-abuse problems, I have never considered the challenges or advantages of being completely online. Other qestions I have in addition to those posed are about financial-backing disclosures, tithing, and the spirtual gift/calling to pastor/preach to others as it pertains to being in an online environment.
“Can church exist without physical gathering?” That’s like asking if marriage can exist without ever being in the same room. Technically? Maybe. Biblically? Let’s not kid ourselves.
The Church is not a stream. It’s a body. Living. Breathing. Built on presence, not pixels. Hebrews 10:25 isn’t a suggestion—it’s a command. “Do not forsake assembling together.” Not, “Log in if it’s convenient” or “Catch the replay between errands.” Assembling is physical. It’s costly. It’s inconvenient. And it’s exactly what shapes disciples.
Yes, Paul wrote letters. Praise God for digital tools when persecution or sickness or shutdowns hit. But let’s not confuse a concession with a commission. Paul didn’t plant churches through parchment and call it done. He traveled, touched, suffered, baptized in rivers, broke bread in homes. Zoom didn’t send him. The Spirit did. On foot.
You want real discipleship? Then it’s gotta get messy. Eyeball-to-eyeball. Shoulder-to-shoulder. Not emoji prayer hands in a chat box. You can’t lay hands on a livestream. You can’t wash feet over Wi-Fi. You can’t rebuke, restore, or bear burdens in a buffer zone.
Digital church is a tool. A supplement. A life raft in a storm. But make it the main course, and you’re starving the body of what it was designed to be: incarnational. Jesus didn’t FaceTime the disciples. He walked with them. Touched lepers. Cried at tombs. Died on wood and rose from stone. That’s the pattern. That’s the call.
So livestream if you must. Praise God for the reach. But don’t settle. Don’t stay there. Don’t trade presence for pixels and call it the same thing. Discipleship costs time, space, awkwardness, accountability. You can’t download that. You have to show up.
Online connection is real. But if that’s all you’ve got, you’re not in a church… you’re in a chatroom with Jesus decals.
—Sincere Seeker. Scripturally savage. Here for the Truth.
1 Like
