My point, @kv100, is that Job is describing God’s creation of him and his life; he isn’t giving a sequence of events in that process. Life begins when the first fertilized cell divides into two cells. Job is describing all the birth process throughout his statement, not what happens when. The Bible is not a scientific textbook; it is an ancient history and set of teachings and must be taken that way for the correct interpretation. I believe you said yourself that that a wisdom book is Hebrew poetry, not a science textbook. Verse 8a is this passage’s summary.
Thank you for your clarification, but you are once again disputing a proposition I never advanced. I did not claim Job 10:8–12 provides a scientific timetable of embryological development or identifies the precise moment a fetus becomes a person. My argument concerns the distinction between God’s work of bodily formation and His impartation of life. Those are the propositions you need to examine.
You insist that Job is not describing a sequence. Yet Job 10:8–12 distinguishes God’s formation of his body from God’s gift of life. Verse 11 describes God clothing him with skin and flesh and knitting him together with bones and sinews, while verse 12 declares, “You gave me life and showed me kindness.” I agree that the passage is poetic and does not establish a precise biological chronology. But poetic language does not automatically eliminate the distinctions expressed within it. More importantly, Genesis 2:7 explicitly narrates God forming Adam, imparting the breath of life, and Adam becoming a living soul. Ezekiel 37:7–10 likewise describes formed bodies without breath, which subsequently receive breath and live. My argument draws upon these passages collectively, not Job 10 in isolation.
You also declare that “life begins when the first fertilized cell divides into two cells.” What exactly establishes that threshold? A fertilized egg is already biologically alive before its first division, so even as a biological definition, your statement requires correction. Furthermore, you have not explained how cellular division establishes the biblical impartation of God’s gift of life or the state of being a living soul. Biological cellular activity and the theological question I am examining are not interchangeable propositions.
Finally, I agree that the Bible is not a scientific textbook. But that observation does not invalidate examining what Scripture actually teaches about creation and life. You cannot simultaneously insist that Job provides no developmental sequence and then introduce your own precise developmental threshold without explaining how you established it. If your objection is that Genesis 2:7 cannot automatically be applied as a timetable for development in the womb, that is a legitimate interpretive question, and I am prepared to examine it. But please address that question directly rather than repeatedly attributing to me claims about Job identifying a particular moment of personhood that I have not made.
A correction must identify an actual error in my argument. Replacing my argument with one you find easier to criticize does not accomplish that.
@kv100, if you said that a fertilized egg is alive, haven’t you answered your own question?
Yeah but there is the diffrence between biological life and God giving the gift of life. They do not have to coincide with each other. God is not bound or compelled to give the gift of life the moment biological life starts, He is God he can decide when inside the womb to give the gift of life. Here is the thing, all fertalised eggs in all pregnancies, around 40% of those fertalised eggs do not implant in the womb, illustration: say 2 million women were pregnant, thats 2 million fertalised eggs, 40% will not implant, thats about 800 000. Then the rest that do implant have to go to pregnancy loss risk such as mischarriage etc. Does it make sense for God to give the gift of life at fertalisation given like almost half wont even implant in the womb and there is more pregnancy loss risk for the remainder? I just wonder what would be happening in the record keeping in the book of life.
Wouldn’t it make more sense that the gift of life is given in the womb when the baby has formed enough so much so it can likely exist outside the womb? Thats were viability comes to play. What do you think?
“Woke-ism” still alive and thriving on planet earth..
J.
This is such a completely ignorant statement; it is not worth debating. I agree with @Johann
It sounds like all you are doing @kv100 is excusing sin.
Peter
Tell me, what sin am I excusing? My post has nothing to do with sin. I suggest you go re-read it in its entirety given that you are seeing things that are not there.
Explain to me exactly how is what I said ignorant?
This is attempting to excuse the sin of murder.
Look at you quoting my old post when I explicitly announced I updated my post to everyone. Refer to my current post please. Stop referring to the past as if it’s something I’m actively doing now.
I quoted from this thread. Your second post. Post #3.
It’s unfortunately no surprise that you would lie about it.
You quoting something in my thread that isn’t in my updated post or about my updated post. Clearly it was in reference to my old post. What matters is what is said in my current updated post.
When you say the words “my post”, I have to assume that you are likely to be referencing something in your secret language that only you know.
You gave the instructions to “read through your whole post”. We are corresponding on a thread of posts that you started. You have posted to the thread numerous times. To which post were you referring?
Nobody knows.
What we do know is that you lied when you said that you had not posted about sin. You do that a lot.
I said my post(as in this current post) has nothing to do with sin. Can you prove that I said what you said? Quote were I said ‘I never posted about sin’? I WOULD LIKE YO SEE THIS THING I NEVER SAID
Man oh man - you must be drunk or something.
“My post has nothing to do with sin” = “I never posted about sin”, and you have them in the same sentence, first affirming and then denying you said it.
I feel like I’m slapping a second grader. Although I know in my head that thorough humiliation is your only hope (whether you do it to yourself, or someone does it to you), I think I’ve had my fill of this conversation.
So, please listen - you do have some good ideas. Unfortunately, someone has taught you at some point in your life that your own ideas about everything are just as good as anyone else’s ideas about everything.
That’s not true.
What is true, is that everything you do and say has an influence on other people. Your influence will be either positive, or negative. They will think you are a genius with a good heart, or a self-absorbed idiot, or somewhere in between.
Here’s an example. You have a habit of ordering me to do what you want me to do. What sort of influence do you suppose that has on me? I will tell you. The needle jumps over to the “self-absorbed idiot” assessment. The respect that you crave just got buried. Once you bury yourself, you just keep piling the dirt higher.
So, good luck to you. God’s blessings. We’ve all been immature and blind to ourselves at some point in our lives. So that can be as short a time as you choose. Start respecting others is a good place to begin moving up.
I’m not gonna entertain your hullucination.
You said I said “I NEVER POSTED ABOUT SIN” show me please where I said that?
SHOW ME THIS THING YOU SAID I SAID THAT DOESN’T EXIST.
Where did I say that? Those words? Liar.
My bad you didn’t use the word never but you said “I had not posted about sin” you even said I lied by not saying that. I’ve never said that, I explicitly said my post has nothing to do with sin, as in this current updated post. So tell me, where did I say " I had not posted about sin"?
I appreciate your acknowledgement. I already told you. I wasn’t quoting you, nor was I intending to quote you. I was was making a true statement about what you said.
I am finished with this conversation.
Explain to me exactly how is what I said ignorant?
You quoting something in my thread that isn’t in my updated post or about my updated post. Clearly it was in reference to my old post. What matters is what is said in my current updated post.
I said my post(as in this current post) has nothing to do with sin. Can you prove that I said what you said? Quote were I said ‘I never posted about sin’? I WOULD LIKE YO SEE THIS THING I NEVER SAID
Enough said. Using your own words, then claiming you did not say it; calling something a sin, then saying you did not. There is no point in carrying on with this nonsense.
Peter